Anwar nak Sekular ke? Hudud ke?

PAS sudah , DAP pun sudah... macam mana pulak dengan Anwar?

Anwar nak Sekular ke? Hudud ke?

Sebagai ketua pembangkang apakah sebenarnya 'stand' Pakatan Rabun terhadap isu Hudud ini...

Rakyat semua hendak mengetahui 'stand' Pakatan Rabun terhadap isu Hudud ini.. mana yang betul dan mana yang tipu...

Jika Pakatan Rabun mengatakan sekular pilihan mereka... maka pelaksanaan Hukum Hudud adalah penipuan yang dirancang oleh PAS untuk mengelirukan pengundi...

Hakikatnya adalah pendirian PAS di dalam Pakatan Rakyat yang menentukan samada PAS tipu pengundi ataupun tidak?

Jika PAS kata mahukan Hudud sedangkan masih mendokong dan bersama Pakatan Rakyat... maka PAS adalah penipu... sebab apa yang dibawa oleh Pakatan Rakyat ialah Pakatan Sekular (PAS).. dan bukanlah Pakatan Islam (PIS)... ianya umpama utara dan selatan, timur dan barat iaitu arah yang bertentangan dan tidak mungkin akan bersama..

Pendirian PAS ini tiada kaitannya dengan UMNO... PAS yang menentukan masa depan Hudud di dalam Pakatan Rakyat sebab UMNO tiada hak untuk memaksa PAS untuk memilih jalan mana? oleh itu UMNO tidak wajar disalahkan...

Maka Hudud terletak ditangan PAS... Jika PAS masih bersama Pakatan Rakyat dan sanggup meninggalkan Hudud.. maka berkuburlah Hudud PAS.. apa yang tinggal hanyalah Negara kebajikan @ Negara Komunis...

Hakikat perbezaan antara PAS dan DAP ini sebenarnya memang wujud sejak azali lagi.... semua mengetahui.. namun kononnya masih hendak 'simpan' perbezaan ini.. persoalannya sampai bila... bila 'Sekular' dan 'bukan sekular' boleh bergabung?

Minyak dan air tidak mungkin bersatu... itulah hukum alam...

Nampaknya DAP pula sebagai abang Long sudah 'sound' awal-awal pendirian PAS?

Adakah PAS diberikan tunjuk sebab kerana kemukakan Hudud tanpa persetujuan Pakatan Rakyat?

Pressure on Anwar to clarify PR stand on hudud grows

By Shannon Teoh
KUALA LUMPUR, Dec 24 — More voices have joined the roiling debate over hudud, with Wanita MCA adding to the number of those calling for Opposition Leader Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim to clarify Pakatan Rakyat’s (PR) stand on the matter.

Earlier today, DAP chairman Karpal Singh had also repeated his call for Anwar to “break his silence, as DAP has done so” with regards to the support for hudud by Pas, the third partner of the coalition.

Pas vice-president Datuk Husam Musa had said that the Islamist party has not forgotten its aim to implement hudud, which prescribes amputation, whipping and stoning for criminal offences, should it come into power.

When DAP criticised the statement, Pas spiritual leader Datuk Nik Abdul Aziz Nik Mat challenged DAP to make its case as to why hudud laws are not acceptable.

“Husam’s statement has resulted in anxiety among non-Muslims in the country. Pas firmly insisting on introducing hudud has ignored the fact that Malaysia is a multi-racial and multi-religious country and the spirit of Federal Constitution”, Wanita MCA chief Datin Paduka Chew Mei Fun said today.

Given that Karpal and DAP secretary-general Lim Guan Eng have already asked Anwar to clarify, Chew said that the de facto PKR leader must “respect the request of the two DAP leaders and respond to Husam's remark accordingly.”

“If Anwar decides to keep quiet, there are only two possibilities, one; Anwar agrees with the remark made by Husam to implement hudud or DAP has been marginalised in PR,” she said.

Karpal had this morning said that the backing of hudud was hurting Pas's credibility and it should be more careful about breaking ranks in the future.

He reminded reporters of the electoral alliance in 1999 where Pas had agreed not to include the formation of an Islamic state in the manifesto.

However, two days before the election, Pas announced it would establish an Islamic state if it took over the state government of Terengganu. Karpal insisted that this proclamation had cost many DAP leaders, including himself and Lim Kit Siang, to lose in the general elections.

With that in mind, he said that DAP had limited “political patience” but was satisfied for now that Husam has backtracked in stating that Pas must obtain a consensus from its PR partners.

“We will still campaign and give our full support to whichever candidate is selected for the Kuala Terengganu by-election,” he assured.

PAS gagal pertahan Hudud dalam Pakatan Rakyat

Nampaknya media pembangkang dan lidah utama mereka Harakah Daily senyap dan berdiam diri sahaja mengenai hukum Hudud yang pernah satu ketika dulu pernah menjadi senjata mereka berdepan dengan UMNO...

Nampaknya kali ini senjata makan tuan....

Hudud yang dilaung-laungkan kini terbukti hanya penipuan semata-mata... Hudud tiba-tiba senyap dan berhenti diukir di Media PAS... ada ramai yang mempertahankan Husam dan ramai juga yang menghentam Husam

Semuanya gara-gara Husam yang terlepas cakap mengenai Hudud semasa program wacana Perdana.... walaupun ada yang berpendapat bahawa soalan tersebut dalah soalan bodoh oleh Khairy Jamaludin... nampaknya yang jawap juga bodoh iaitu saudara Husam...

Penyokong PAS tidak patut salahkan UMNO kerana yang menyanggah kenyataan Hudud PAS adalah DAP... bukannya UMNO... peliknya penyokong PAS tetap salahkan UMNO.... sedangkan DAP yang menentang Hudud PAS... jadi patut PAS kenalah hentam DAP balik yang menentang PAS... teringat ceramah Datuk Ismail Kamus dahulu "ini bukan adil, ni bangang namanya"..

DAP pula secara automatik nampaknya terus bangkit dan menentang hasrat PAS itu sama ada Lim Kit Siang mahupun Lim Guan Eng sama sahaja anak-beranak ni... atas alasan Hudud tidak terdapat dalam manifesto Pakatan Rakyat pada Pilihanraya Umum yang lalu..... Pakatan Rakyat mahukan negara sekular...

Tapi itulah.. nampaknya isu UMNO tolak hudud , UMNO tolak negara Islam, isu UMNO sekular kini tidak boleh diguna lagi...

Nampaknya Hudud PAS semakin kabur dan bakal berkubur... kerana bukan sahaja tidak dapat dilaksanakan bahkan hendak dimasukkan di dalam manifesto Pakatan Rakyat pun tidak boleh... Bukan kerana UMNO hendak 'kuburkan' Hudud PAS, tetapi PAS sendiri yang 'kuburkan Hudud.

Penyokong PAS tidak wajar menyalahkan UMNO kerana PAS gagal meletakkan Hudud dalam manifesto Pakatan Rakyat.

Jadi apakah manifesto PAS di Kuala Terengganu ini... adakah Hudud termasuk dalam manifesto ataupun tidak.....

Karpal: Nik Aziz’s move an expediency

PETALING JAYA: The threat by Datuk Nik Abdul Aziz Nik Mat – that PAS would implement hudud laws – is nothing less than a political expediency without considering the political reality in the country, Karpal Singh said.

The DAP chairman said the PAS spiritual leader also did not take into account the reasons given by DAP for objecting to the implementation of the laws in a multi-racial and multi-lingual country like Malaysia.

“Nik Aziz has asked for reasons we are objecting to the move. To start off, the Federal Constitution does not provide for an Islamic state from which could follow introduction of Islamic criminal laws like hudud.

“Next, PAS cannot afford to ignore the five-man unanimous decision of the Supreme Court, the highest court in the land, in 1988 that the country was not an Islamic state, but a secular state,” he said in a statement yesterday.

He noted that it was Tun Salleh Abbas, who was at one time a PAS state exco member in Terengganu, who headed the five-man panel of the Supreme Court which made that judicial pronouncement.

“The Federal Constitution is a sacred document which must be accepted and respected by everyone, including PAS. PAS leaders, including Nik Aziz, should not defy and continuously be in contempt of it when insisting on the implementation of hudud laws in the country.

“It is wrong for PAS, for political expediency, to crave for what is clearly against the national interest,” he added.